Jude Collins

Saturday, 5 May 2012

Come on, you reds! Or maybe not...

You going to watch the FA Cup Final today?  I will, although every so often I remember talking to the guide at the Nou Camp a couple of summers ago.  He asked me what Irish soccer club I supported. When I said, um,  none really but that I always liked to see Arsenal win, I felt  uneasy. Was it healthy that as an Irish person, my footballing loyalties ignored every Irish club and clamped onto an English one? And I got to thinking how, at primary school, we used to play Cowboys and Indians, and how as teenagers we were really into Elvis and Buddy Holly and Eddie Cochrane. 

Get the pattern? In soccer, in archetypal heroes, in pop music, I’ve spent most of my life ignoring the soccer, the legendary heroes, the music of my own country. Some say that’s fine- my own sons say it’s fine. Why wouldn’t you want to enjoy good American pop music, or jazz, or films, or writers? Why cut yourself off from a broader vision of the world? They’re half-right, I think. 

There are people who are so insular, they focus solely on whatever is Irish-made and reject all foreign influences and attractions. That’s pretty sad. But I think the danger most of us suffer from is that we tend to dismiss what is our own and position ourselves as little English people or little Americans, passing over what is Irish as being almost by definition not worth bothering about. Except, of course, the Irish product has been approved by London or New York or other influential outside capitals. Then we'll applaud it.

 I used to see Anything But Irish attitude when I taught  media studies. In discussion of tabloids and broadsheets, students invariably referred to the Sun or the Times newspapers –very rarely to the Sunday Life or the Indo  Irish Times. It’s as if  anything we have ourselves must be at best so second-rate, it’s not worth bothering about. In short, we’re so in thrall to cultural empires – Britain and the US – it seems perfectly natural to position ourselves culturally as English or American.

There’s a term for that kind of thing: soft power. And the great majority on this island, north and south, can’t wait to bend the knee and adopt the cultural trappings that soft power says we should. 


  1. But is there such a thing as the perfect paper?As recently as last week you were berating the Irish Times for its quality of journalism.I gather the Indo stable is not always to your liking.The public seemed disinclined to keep Daily Ireland alive.Perhaps the only option is to appreciate the best journalism in whatever paper it comes.

  2. The reality is people will support whomever can compete at the top level in that field as that's where the best performers are. George Best, Liam Brady, Roy Keane, all of them had to go abroad because that's where the best soccer is played. Is there one player on the RoI squad going to this year's Euros who doesn't play for an English club? We have the players who are good enough to qualify, but we can't support them here.

    Take rugby: we're able to keep the best players here, so if you ask 20 people what club they support it's probably going to be one of the provinces, as opposed to an English club.

    1. Our captain, Robbie Keane, plays outside of England, as does Aiden McGeady. Admittedly, they don't play in Ireland either.

  3. What did the Romans ever do for us?

  4. I think everyone's getting your pattern now, Jude.

  5. The aquaduct?

  6. Because the admin of this web site is working, no question very shortly it will be
    well-known, due to its quality contents.
    my web page: Wedding Photographer in Yorkshire